Home > Menus
Menus

P.J. CLARKE’S LINCOLN SQUARE MENU

Raw Bar: Third Avenue
We know how to pick`em
You know it’s fresh when it’s on the Lincoln Square restaurant menu. Our oysters and clams are handpicked by our Culinary Director daily. Curious about today’s catch? Call us to find out.
see more

Soup

  • CREAMY TOMATO SOUP $17
    With farmstead cheddar toast
  • NEW ENGLAND CLAM CHOWDER $18
    With Double smoked bacon, potato & cream

For the table

  • CHEESESTEAK EGG ROLLS $18
    With crushed pepper dipping sauce
  • MARYLAND CRAB FRITTERS $26
    With fresno chili remoulade
  • RHODE ISLAND CALAMARI $21
    With pickled peppers, garlic & olive oil
  • ZUCCHINI & EGGPLANT CHIPS $18
    With tzatziki & crispy feta cheese
  • MEATBALLS $18
    With beef, pork & homemade tomato sauce
  • OVEN-BAKED PRETZEL BITES $14
    With cheesy brooklyn lager rarebit
  • WARM BAGUETTE $6
    With whipped honey butter

Mussels Frites

MARINIÈRE
With white wine, butter, shallots,
leeks & herbs
$29
THAI STYLE
coconut cream curry, garlic & cilantro
$29

Classics

  • CHICKEN PAILLARD $29
    With arugula, sweet shallot,
    
shaved parmesan & lemonette
  • COUNTRY CHICKEN POT PIE $27
    With A cheddar cheese crust
  • BAKED MACARONI & CHEESE $19
    With Double smoked bacon & peas
  • NEWPORT STEAK FRITES $39
    sea salt fries, maitre d’ butter
  • GENTLEMAN’S CHOPPED STEAK $28
    chopped sirloin, mushroom, caramelized onion, gravy, A sunny side up egg & rosti potatoes

Salads

  • TUNA NICOISE SALAD $29
    confit italian tuna & dijon vinaigrette
  • LITTLE GEM CAESAR SALAD $18
    little gem romaine, Lettuce, parmesan,
    croutons & white anchovy dressing
  • MEDITERRANEAN CHOPPED SALAD $19
    persian cucumbers, bell peppers, celery, fennel, tomato, chickpeas, kalamata olives, feta, 
radishes & mint
  • + roast chicken $10
  • + faroe island salmon $11
  • + jumbo shrimp $15

Oysters And...

EAST COAST OYSTERS
1/2 Dozen | Dozen
$25 | $48
LONG ISLAND LITTLENECKS
1/2 Dozen | Dozen
$16 | $26
JUMBO GULF SHRIMP COCKTAIL
classic cocktail sauce
$23
OYSTERS ROCKEFELLER [6]
spinach, pernod & shaved parmesan
$25
CLAMS CASINO [6]
bacon, panko & parsley butter
$19
TUNA TARTARE TACOS
mango, ginger, jalapeño & ginger sauce
$18
LOBSTER COCKTAIL
marie rose sauce
$34
4X4X4
4 oysters, 4 jumbo shrimp &
4 littleneck clams
$44
THE DELUXE
16 Oysters, 8 Jumbo Shrimp
6 Little Neck Clams,
Maine Lobster & Chilled Mussels
$145

Lobster Roll

Maine lobster meat & toasted brioche bun
Lobster Roll
CONNECTICUT STYLE
With warm melted butter
$35
MAINE STYLE
With Mayonnaise, lemon & Chives
$35

Seafood

  • PROPER FISH & CHIPS $29
    craft beer Battered fresh cod,
    chunky tartar sauce & malt vinegar
  • PAN Roasted SALMON $34
    honey dijon glaze & sautéed broccolini
  • SEARED ATLANTIC COD $33
    smoked bacon & corn succotash
  • LINGUINI $28
    whole & chopped littleneck clams,
    white wine, garlic & parsley

Sandwiches

served with gaufrettes
  • CRUNCHY CHICKEN SANDWICH $24
    japanese pickles, bibb lettuce & 

    cracked black pepper buttermilk dressing
  • ROAST TURKEY CLUB $28
    smoked bacon, tomato jam, asiago,
    dill mayonnaise & whole grain toast
  • MARYLAND JUMBO LUMP CRAB CAKE $32
    With chunky tartar sauce & chef’s coleslaw

Maine Lobster Cobb

Maine lobster tail & claw, Bibb lettuce, tomato, scallion, bacon lardons, avocado, blue cheese crumbles & soft boiled egg
$38

Clarke's Burgers

Served with sea salt fries
  • THE PJS 1884 CHEESEBURGER $24
    With lettuce, tomato, onion & american cheese
  • THE BBQ BLUE $26
    With crispy onions, BBQ sauce & blue cheese crumbles
  • THE CADILLAC $27
    With double smoked bacon, american cheese, lettuce, tomato & onion
  • TRIO OF MINI BURGERS $25
    BBQ blue, cadillac & the PJs 1884 cheeseburger
  • THE BARTENDER’S BURGER $25
    smoked bacon & mushroom confit,
    asiago cheese, with special sauce
  • ADD-ONS: +$3 each
    american cheese, blue cheese, aged gruyere, vermont cheddar, double smoked bacon, sautéed onions, fried egg, smoked bacon, mushroom confit, avocado

Sides

  • PARMESAN TRUFFLE FRIES $14
    with rosemary
  • SEA SALT FRIES $11
  • CRISPY ONION STRINGS $11
    With Dijon Aioli
  • SAUTÉED SPINACH $11
    With garlic & olive oil
  • BROCCOLINI $11
    With olive oil & parmesan
*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

Soup

  • CREAMY TOMATO SOUP $17
    With farmstead cheddar toast
  • NEW ENGLAND CLAM CHOWDER $18
    With Double smoked bacon, potato & cream

For the table

  • CHEESESTEAK EGG ROLLS $18
    With crushed pepper dipping sauce
  • MARYLAND CRAB FRITTERS $26
    With fresno chili remoulade
  • RHODE ISLAND CALAMARI $21
    With pickled peppers, garlic & olive oil
  • ZUCCHINI & EGGPLANT CHIPS $18
    With tzatziki & crispy feta cheese
  • MEATBALLS $18
    With beef, pork & homemade tomato sauce
  • OVEN-BAKED PRETZEL BITES $14
    With cheesy brooklyn lager rarebit
  • WARM BAGUETTE $6
    With whipped honey butter

Mussels Frites

MARINIÈRE
With white wine, butter, shallots,
leeks & herbs
$29
THAI STYLE
coconut cream curry, garlic & cilantro
$29

Clarke's Burgers

Served with sea salt fries
  • THE PJS 1884 CHEESEBURGER $24
    With lettuce, tomato, onion & american cheese
  • THE BBQ BLUE $26
    With crispy onions, BBQ sauce & blue cheese crumbles
  • THE CADILLAC $27
    With double smoked bacon, american cheese, lettuce, tomato & onion
  • TRIO OF MINI BURGERS $25
    BBQ blue, cadillac & the PJs 1884 cheeseburger
  • THE BARTENDER’S BURGER $25
    smoked bacon & mushroom confit,
    asiago cheese, with special sauce
  • ADD-ONS: +$3 each
    american cheese, blue cheese, aged gruyere, vermont cheddar, double smoked bacon, sautéed onions, fried egg, smoked bacon, mushroom confit, avocado

Oysters And...

EAST COAST OYSTERS
1/2 Dozen | Dozen
$25 | $48
LONG ISLAND LITTLENECKS
1/2 Dozen | Dozen
$16 | $26
JUMBO GULF SHRIMP COCKTAIL
classic cocktail sauce
$23
OYSTERS ROCKEFELLER [6]
spinach, pernod & shaved parmesan
$25
CLAMS CASINO [6]
bacon, panko, parsley butter
$19
TUNA TARTARE TACOS
mango, ginger, jalapeño & ginger sauce
$18
LOBSTER COCKTAIL
marie rose sauce
$34
4X4X4
4 oysters, 4 jumbo shrimp &
4 littleneck clams
$44
THE DELUXE
16 Oysters, 8 Jumbo Shrimp
6 Little Neck Clams,
Maine Lobster & Chilled Mussels
$145

Lobster Roll

Maine lobster meat & toasted brioche bun
Lobster Roll
CONNECTICUT STYLE
With warm melted butter
$35
MAINE STYLE
With Mayonnaise, lemon & Chives
$35

Sides

  • PARMESAN TRUFFLE FRIES $14
    with rosemary
  • SEA SALT FRIES $11
  • CRISPY ONION STRINGS $11
    With Dijon Aioli
  • SAUTÉED SPINACH $11
    With garlic & olive oil
  • BROCCOLINI $11
    With olive oil & parmesan

Steaks

  • CERTIFIED BLACK ANGUS
choice of maitre d’ butter, blu butter or naked
  • NEWPORT STEAK FRITES $39
    sea salt fries
  • CENTER-CUT FILET MIGNON [8 oz] $52
  • PRIME NY STRIP STEAK [14OZ] $58
  • PORTERHOUSE FOR 2 [32OZ]  $135
    sliced off the bone

Seafood

  • PROPER FISH & CHIPS $29
    craft beer Battered fresh cod,
    
chunky tartar sauce & malt vinegar
  • PAN ROAST SALMON $34
    honey dijon glaze & sautéed broccolini
  • SEARED ATLANTIC COD $33
    smoked bacon & corn succotash
  • LINGUINI $28
    whole & chopped littleneck clams,
    white wine, garlic & parsley

Classics

  • CHICKEN PAILLARD $29
    With arugula, sweet shallot, shaved parmesan & lemonette
  • COUNTRY CHICKEN POT PIE $27
    With a cheddar cheese crust
  • BAKED MACARONI & CHEESE $19
    With Double smoked bacon & peas
  • GENTLEMAN’S CHOPPED STEAK $28
    chopped sirloin, mushroom, caramelized onion, gravy, sunny side up egg & rosti potatoes

Salads

  • LITTLE GEM CAESAR SALAD $18
    little gem romaine, Lettuce, parmesan, croutons & white anchovy dressing
  • MEDITERRANEAN CHOPPED SALAD $19
    persian cucumbers, bell peppers, celery, fennel, tomato, chickpeas, kalamata olives, feta, 
radishes & mint
  • + roast chicken $10
  • + faroe island salmon $11
  • + jumbo shrimp $15

Maine Lobster Cobb

Maine lobster tail & claw, Bibb lettuce, tomato, scallion, bacon lardons, avocado, blue cheese crumbles & soft boiled egg
$38
*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk for foodborne illness.

Griddle

Available until 2pm
  • FRENCH TOAST $21
    berries, whipped cream, orange zest
  • FAT & FLUFFY PANCAKE $22
    maple brown butter, apricot jam
  • OVEN BAKED DUTCH BABY $22
    popover pancake with powdered sugar, strawberries, blueberries, bananas

Eggs

served with baby greens
Available until 2pm
  • CLASSIC EGGS BENEDICT $24
    southern ham, hollandaise, crumpets
  • SMOKED SALMON BENEDICT $24
    hollandaise, crumpets
  • TWO EGGS & ENGLISH MUFFIN $19
    choice of bacon, ham or tomato
  • BREAKFAST SANDWICH $22
    two eggs, smoked bacon, avocado, vermont cheddar, herb butter
  • AVOCADO TOAST $23
    poached egg, feta cheese, calabrian chili, pickled shallot
  • SPINACH & GOAT CHEESE OMELET $22
    baby spinach
  • SMOKED SALMON TOAST $23
    whipped cream cheese, capers, ‘everything’ red onion, marble rye

Soup

  • CREAMY TOMATO SOUP $17
    With farmstead cheddar toast
  • NEW ENGLAND CLAM CHOWDER $18
    With Double smoked bacon, potato & cream

For the table

  • CHEESESTEAK EGG ROLLS $18
    With crushed pepper dipping sauce
  • MARYLAND CRAB FRITTERS $26
    fresno chili remoulade
  • RHODE ISLAND CALAMARI $21
    pickled peppers, garlic, olive oil
  • ZUCCHINI & EGGPLANT CHIPS $18
    tzatziki, crispy feta cheese
  • MEATBALLS $18
    beef, pork, homemade tomato sauce
  • OVEN-BAKED PRETZEL BITES $14
    cheesy brooklyn lager rarebit
  • WARM BAGUETTE $6
    whipped honey butter

Oysters And...

EAST COAST OYSTERS
1/2 Dozen | Dozen
$25 | $48
LONG ISLAND LITTLENECKS
1/2 Dozen | Dozen
$16 | $26
JUMBO GULF SHRIMP COCKTAIL
classic cocktail sauce
$23
OYSTERS ROCKEFELLER [6]
spinach, pernod & shaved parmesan
$25
CLAMS CASINO [6]
bacon, panko, parsley butter
$19
TUNA TARTARE TACOS
mango, ginger, jalapeño, ginger sauce
$18
LOBSTER COCKTAIL
marie rose sauce
$34
4X4X4
4 oysters, 4 jumbo shrimp &
4 littleneck clams
$44
THE DELUXE
16 Oysters, 8 Jumbo Shrimp
6 Little Neck Clams,
Maine Lobster & Chilled Mussels
$145

Lobster Roll

Maine lobster meat & toasted brioche bun
Lobster Roll
CONNECTICUT STYLE
With warm melted butter
$35
MAINE STYLE
With Mayonnaise, lemon & Chives
$35

Clarke's Burgers

Served with sea salt fries
  • THE PJS 1884 CHEESEBURGER $24
    With lettuce, tomato, onion & american cheese
  • THE BBQ BLUE $26
    With crispy onions, BBQ sauce & blue cheese crumbles
  • THE CADILLAC $27
    With double smoked bacon, american cheese, lettuce, tomato & onion
  • TRIO OF MINI BURGERS $25
    BBQ blue, cadillac & the PJs 1884 cheeseburger
  • THE BARTENDER’S BURGER $25
    smoked bacon & mushroom confit,
    asiago cheese, with special sauce
  • ADD-ONS: +$3 each
    american cheese, blue cheese, aged gruyere, vermont cheddar, double smoked bacon, sautéed onions, fried egg, smoked bacon, mushroom confit, avocado

Maine Lobster Cobb

Maine lobster tail & claw, bib lettuce, tomato, scallion, bacon lardons, avocado, blue cheese crumbles, soft boiled egg
$38

Salads

  • TUNA NICOISE SALAD $29
    confit italian tuna & dijon vinaigrette
  • LITTLE GEM CAESAR SALAD $18
    little gem romaine, Lettuce, parmesan,
    croutons & white anchovy dressing
  • MEDITERRANEAN CHOPPED SALAD $19
    persian cucumbers, bell peppers, celery, fennel, tomato, chickpeas, kalamata olives, feta, 
radishes & mint
  • + roast chicken $10
  • + faroe island salmon $11
  • + jumbo shrimp $15

Sides

  • PARMESAN TRUFFLE FRIES $14
    with rosemary
  • DOUBLE SMOKED BACON $6
  • FREE RANGE EGG $4
  • TOAST & BUTTER $3
  • WARM CRUMPET & JAM $6
  • MIXED BERRIES $6
*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk for foodborne illness.

Cocktails

Spritzer

  • HUGO SPRITZ
    St Germain Elderflower, Prosecco, Fresh Mint, Lime Wedge
  • APEROL SPRITZ
    Aperol, Prosecco, Club Soda, Slice Of Orange
  • RED ON RED
    Caffo Red Bitter, Stellare Primo, Prosecco, Slice Of Orange & Lemon Peel
  • GARDEN PARTY
    Fort Hamilton Cucumber Vodka, Stellare Primo, Giffard Rhubarb, Prosecco, Lemon Slice
  • FIRST CLASS
    Dark Rum, Lime Juice, Cane Syrup, Prosecco, Lime Twist

Seasonal

  • SGROPPINO
    Lemon Sorbet, Vodka, Prosecco & Fresh Mint

Classics

  • SMOKY OLD FASHIONED
    Willett’s Old Bardstown Bourbon, Walnut Bitters, Maple Syrup, Orange Peel, Black Cherry
  • PERFECT MANHATTAN
    Sazerac Rye, Sweet & Dry Vermouth, Amarena Cherry
  • BLUECOAT NEGRONI
    Bluecoat Gin, Campari, Sweet Vermouth, Orange Peel
  • PALOMA
    100% Agave Blanco Tequila, Grapefruit, Lime, Fever Tree Pink Grapefruit
  • MOSCOW MULE
    Grainger’s Organic Vodka, Lime Juice, Fever
Tree Ginger Beer

Jumbo Bloody Mary

3oz of Grainger’s organic Vodka and our 1884 Bloody Mix with the Proper Accruements
$20
ADD SHRIMP +$3 each

Currents

  • QUEENS GAMBIT
    Empress 1908 Original Indigo Gin, St. Germain Elderflower Liqueur, White Cranberry, Fresh Lemon Juice
  • PASSION FRUIT COSMOPOLITAN
    Sobieski Vodka, Cointreau, Passion Fruit Puree, 
Fresh Lime Juice
  • SPICY CUCUMBER MARGARITA
    Curamia Blanco Tequila, Triple Sec, Fresh Lime Juice, Simple Syrup, Jalapeño & Cucumber
  • LYCHEE MARTINI
    e11even vodka, lychee puree, double lychee garnish
  • MR. BLACK ESPRESSO MARTINI
    Sobieski Vanilla Vodka, Espresso, Mr. Black Cold Brew Liqueur, Simple Syrup

Wine

glass/bottle

SPARKLING

  • PROSECCO $14/$52
    la forestina doc · it
  • CREMANT $18/$65
    victorine de chastenay · fr
  • CHAMPAGNE $135
    veuve clicquot · fr

ROSÉ

  • ROSÉ $17/$55
    cht. berne romance ‘25 · fr
  • ROSÉ $18/$65
    chateau routas ‘25 · fr

WHITE

  • ALBARINO $15/$58
    burgans ‘24 · es
  • CHARDONNAY $17/$65
    sea sun ‘24 · ca
  • MUSCADET $15/$65
    les prieres granite ‘24 · ca
  • PINOT GRIGIO $15/$52
    circa ‘25 · it
  • SANCERRE $24/$75
    le roi des pierres · ca
  • SAUVIGNON BLANC $16/$58
    wildsong ‘24 · nz
  • CHARDONNAY $80
    frank family ‘23 · ca
  • SAUVIGNON BLANC $60
    earthsong ‘24 · NZ

red

  • CABERNET SAUVIGNON $16/$50
    grounded ‘24 · ca
  • CABERNET FRANC $15/$49
    scarpetta ‘23 · it
  • MALBEC $14/$51
    pie de palo ‘23 · arg
  • PINOT NOIR $17/$58
    la crema ‘23 · ca
  • BORDEAUX $57
    cru monplaisir ‘22 · fr
  • BURGUNDY $155
    louis latour ‘20 · fr
  • CABERNET SAUVIGNON $55
    ghost pines · ca
  • CABERNET SAUVIGNON $155
    heitz cellar ‘21 · ca
  • CHIANTI CLASSICO $65
    gagliole rubiolo ‘23 · it
  • PINOT NOIR $85
    brick house ‘24 · or

Zero Proof

  • VINADA AIREN SPARKLING NON-ALCOHOLIC WHITE WINE
    netherlands
  • PUTTIN’ ON THE SPRITZ
    ghia apertif, passionfruit puree, vinada sparkling ‘wine’, bab louie orange bitters, simple syrup, orange wheel, fresh mint
  • SUNNYSIDE
    grapefruit juice, spicy agave, lime juice, tonic, and tajín salt rim

Beer & Cider

DRAFT BEER

  • BRONX BREWERY TOGETHXR LAGER $9
  • GOOSE ISLAND IPA $9
  • GUINNESS $10
  • KONA BIG WAVE GOLDEN ALE $9
  • LAGUNITAS LITTLE SUMPIN’ SUMPIN’ IPA $9
  • STELLA ARTOIS $9

BOTTLES & CANS

  • BUDWEISER $8
    missouri
  • BUD LIGHT $8
    missouri
  • COORS LIGHT $8
    colorado
  • CORONA $8
    mexico
  • DOC’S CIDER $11
    new york
  • GOOSE ISLAND MATILDA BELGIAN ALE $10
    illinois
  • HALF ACRE DAISY CUTTER PALE ALE $10
    illinois
  • HEINEKEN $8
    netherlands
  • MICHELOB ULTRA $8
    ireland
  • MODELO ESPECIAL $9
    mexico

NEAR BEER

  • ATHLETIC FREE WAVE HAZY IPA $9
    connecticut
  • GUINNESS DRAUGHT 0.0 $11
    ireland
  • STELLA ARTOIS 0.0 $9
    belgium

Premium Spirits

Tequila

  • BANHEZ ENSAMBLE MEZCAL
    oaxaca · mexico
  • CASAMIGOS BLANCO
    jalisco · mexico
  • CASAMIGOS REPOSADO
    jalisco · mexico
  • DEL MAGUEY VIDA ARTESANAL MEZCAL
    oaxaca · mexico
  • DON JULIO BLANCO
    jalisco · mexico
  • CURAMIA BLANCO
    jalisco · mexico
  • CURAMIA REPOSADO
    jalisco · mexico
  • LALO BLANCO
    jalisco · mexico

SCOTCH

  • MACALLAN 18 YEAR
    Scotland
  • JOHNNIE WALKER BLUE
    Scotland
  • LAGAVULIN 16 YEAR
    Scotland
  • BALVENIE DOUBLEWOOD 12 YEAR
    Scotland

BOURBON

  • BUFFALO TRACE
    Frankfort · KY
  • BLANTON’S
    Frankfort · KY
  • WELLER
    Frankfort · KY
  • E.H. TAYLOR JR. SMALL BATCH
    Frankfort · KY
  • EAGLE RARE 10 YEAR
    Frankfort · KY

RYE

  • MICHTER’S RYE
    Louisville · KY
  • SAZERAC RYE
    Frankfort · KY

GIN

  • THE BOTANIST
    Islay · Scotland
  • HENDRICK’S
    Girvan · Scotland

Desserts

KEY LIME PIE
vanilla wafer crust, whipped cream
$15
NEW YORK CHEESECAKE
cherry compote
$15
BROWNIE SUNDAE
vanilla ice cream, chocolate sauce, whipped cream, cherry
$15
STRAWBERRIES AND CREAM
whipped cream and orange zest
$15

Coffee & Tea

PROUDLY SERVING LAVAZZA

GRAN RISERVA
GRAN RISERVA DEK BLU
ESPRESSO INTENSO

PROUDLY SERVING Harney & Sons

ENGLISH BREAKFAST
ORGANIC EARL GREY
EGYPTIAN CHAMOMILE