Classic American Dishes: Favorites From P.J. Clarke’s

At P.J. Clarke’s, we’re proud to serve up some of the best classic comfort food around – and we’ve been doing it since 1884, so we’re pretty good at it. Our Third Avenue menu is filled with diverse American classics – let’s take a look at some of our favorites.

A Legendary Burger Bite

There’s nothing quite like sinking your teeth into a juicy burger. We’ve been perfecting our craft for years, and it shows.

  • The P.J.’s 1884 Cheeseburger: Sometimes, simple is best. Our classic cheeseburger is a timeless treat. Fresh beef, gooey cheese, and classic toppings make it pure comfort food. Order fries on the side, and you’ve got yourself the perfect combo. 
  • The Cadillac Burger: This isn’t your average burger. It’s a stacked masterpiece: double-smoked bacon, melty American cheese, fresh tomatoes, onions, and crisp lettuce. Yes, please!
Coastal Cravings

Coastal Cravings

If you’re craving some seafood, we’ve got you covered. Our seafood menu features dishes unique to different parts of the country, as American as apple pie. You can be transported anywhere from Maine to Louisiana in just one bite! 

  • Lobster Roll: Fresh lobster meat piled high on a buttery brioche bun. Choose between our Connecticut style with hot melted butter or our Maine style, chilled with mayo, lemon, and chive.
  • New England Clam Chowder: Rich, creamy, and packed with flavor, our clam chowder is the perfect bowl of comfort, with a touch of smoky bacon for extra depth and deliciousness.
  • Shrimp Gumbo: This Louisiana-inspired dish is full of flavor. Andouille sausage, okra, and our secret blend of spices create a truly unforgettable flavor.

P.J. Clarke’s: Serving Delicious Classic American Dishes

Whether you’re craving a hearty burger or a taste of the sea, P.J. Clarke’s is your go-to spot for classic American food. It’s that quintessential home cooking elevated to an art form, the most popular and flavorful favorites from across the USA perfected in our kitchens for over 100 years. Come on by and let us treat you – make a reservation today!

Classic American Dishes: Favorites From P.J. Clarke’s

Oyster & Wine Pairing: NYC’s Freshest Flavors

If you’re a seafood lover, you know there’s nothing quite like enjoying fresh oysters, especially when they’re straight from the raw bar at P.J. Clarke’s. Our Lincoln Square menu is packed with some of the best oysters around, each one offering its own unique taste of the ocean. And when you pair them with the right wine? Simply incredible.
Back to blog