Home > Menus
Menus

P.J. CLARKE'S SIDECAR MENU

Raw Bar: Third Avenue

We know how to pick`em

We’re picky, so you don’t have to be. At P.J. Clarke’s Sidecar, our Culinary Director selects only the highest quality oysters and clams daily, ensuring they’re the freshest on the market. Call us today to see what’s on ice.
see more
Lobster Roll
Lobster Roll
  • CONNECTICUT STYLE $35
    Maine Lobster Meat, Toasted Brioche Bun, served with Old Bay Chips, Warm Melted Butter
  • MAINE STYLE $35
    Maine Lobster Meat, Toasted Brioche Bun, served with Old Bay Chips, Mayonnaise, lemon
Soup
  • CREAMY TOMATO SOUP $16
    farmstead cheddar toast
  • NEW ENGLAND CLAM CHOWDER $18
    Smoked bacon, potato, cream
Salads
  • Wilted Spinach $19
    Warm Bacon Dressing, Egg, Red Onion
  • Little Gem Caesar Salad $19
    Little Gem Romaine, Parmesan, 
Kitchen Croutons
  • Chopped Market Salad $21
    Chopped Radicchio, Cucumber, Bell Peppers, Celery, Fennel, Green Beans, Chick Peas, Kalamata Olives
  • Add
    Roast Chicken Breast +9
    Salmon +10
    Shrimp +14
For the Table
  • CHEESESTEAK EGG ROLLS $18
    crushed pepper dipping sauce
  • English Pea Cucumber Hummus $19
    With Mint, Toasted Pita & Crudites
  • Zucchini & Eggplant Chips $18
    Tzatziki, Crispy Feta Cheese
  • Rhode Island Calamari $19
    Pickled Peppers, Garlic, Olive Oil
  • Oysters Rockefeller $17
    Spinach, Shallots, Absinthe
  • Oysters On The Half Shell $24/$46
    ½ Dozen | Dozen
  • Jumbo Gulf Shrimp Cocktail $22
    Classic Cocktail Sauce
  • Tuna Tartare $18
    Mango, Ginger, Jalapeno, Pickled Cucumbers
  • Park Avenue Steak Tartare $21
    Capers, Cornichons, Shaved Horseradish, Dijon Mustard, Shallots & crostini
  • Warm Baguette $6
    Whipped Honey Butter
Sandwiches
Served With Sea Salt Fries
  • Sidecar Club $28
    Roast turkey, Smoked Bacon, Avocado, Asiago, Tomato Jam, Dill Mayonnaise, Whole Grain Toast
  • Maryland Jumbo Lump Crab Cake $32
    Chunky Tartare Sauce & Chef’s Coleslaw
  • Prime Rib French Dip $34
    Horseradish, au jus, toasted bun
Entrees
  • Montauk Filet Of Sole $34
    Lemon Caper Brown Butter & Charred Asparagus
  • Proper Fish & Chips $29
    Craft Beer Batter, Tartar Sauce, Malt Vinegar
  • Gentleman’s Chopped Steak $28
    Chopped Sirloin, Mushrooms, Caramelized Onion Gravy, Crispy Smashed Potatoes & Sunny Side Up Egg
  • Newport Steak Frites $37
    Sea Salt Fries, Maitre D’ Butter
  • Poached Salmon $34
    Asparagus, Dijon Dill Cream
  • Bluewood Chicken Milanese $29
    Arugula, Cherry Tomatoes & Blu Cheese
  • The PJs 1884 Cadillac Burger $27
    Anyway you like it
  • Maine Lobster Cobb $38
    Maine Lobster Meat, Bibb Lettuce, Tomato, Scallion, Bacon Lardons, Avocado, Blue Cheese Crumbles, Soft-Boiled Egg
Sides
  • Crispy Smashed Potatoes $10
    Sour Cream & Chives
  • Charred Asparagus $10
  • CRISPY ONION STRINGS $10
    Dijon Aioli
  • Sautéed Spinach $10
    Garlic & Olive Oil
  • PARMESAN TRUFFLE FRIES $12
  • Sea Salt Fries $10
*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk for foodborne illness.
Certified Black Angus Steak
Of Course Our Steaks Come With Frites and Your Choice of Sauce:
  • NEWPORT STEAK $37
    Maitre d’ Butter, au poivre, 
blu butter or naked
  • Boneless ribeye (10 oz) $45
    Maitre d’ Butter, au poivre, 
blu butter or naked
  • 1884 T-BONE STEAK (16 oz) $48
    Maitre d’ Butter, au poivre, 
blu butter or naked
Salads
  • Wilted Spinach $19
    Warm Bacon Dressing, Egg, Red Onion
  • Little Gem Caesar Salad $19
    Little Gem Romaine, Parmesan, 
Kitchen Croutons
  • Chopped Market Salad $21
    Chopped Radicchio, Cucumber, Bell Peppers, Celery, Fennel, Green Beans, Chick Peas, Kalamata Olives
  • Add
    Roast Chicken Breast +9
    Salmon +10
    Shrimp +14
For the Table
  • CHEESESTEAK EGG ROLLS $18
    crushed pepper dipping sauce
  • English Pea Cucumber Hummus $19
    With Mint, Toasted Pita & Crudites
  • Zucchini & Eggplant Chips $18
    Tzatziki, Crispy Feta Cheese
  • Rhode Island Calamari $19
    Pickled Peppers, Garlic, Olive Oil
  • Oysters Rockefeller $17
    Spinach, Shallots, Absinthe
  • Oysters On The Half Shell $24/$46
    ½ Dozen | Dozen
  • Jumbo Gulf Shrimp Cocktail $22
    Classic Cocktail Sauce
  • Tuna Tartare $18
    Mango, Ginger, Jalapeno, Pickled Cucumbers
  • Park Avenue Steak Tartare $21
    Capers, Cornichons, Shaved Horseradish, Dijon Mustard, Shallots & crostini
  • Warm Baguette $6
    Whipped Honey Butter
Soup
  • CREAMY TOMATO SOUP $16
    farmstead cheddar toast
  • NEW ENGLAND CLAM CHOWDER $18
    smoked bacon, potato, cream
Entrees
  • Montauk Filet Of Sole $34
    Lemon Caper Brown Butter & Charred Asparagus
  • Poached Salmon $34
    Asparagus, Dijon Dill Cream
  • Bluewood Chicken Milanese $29
    Arugula, Cherry Tomatoes & Blu Cheese
  • Maryland Jumbo Lump Crab Cakes $38
    Chunky Tartare Sauce
  • Gentleman’s Chopped Steak $28
    Chopped Sirloin, Mushrooms, Caramelized Onion Gravy, Crispy Smashed Potatoes & Sunny Side Up Egg
  • Maine Lobster Cobb $38
    Maine Lobster Meat, Bibb Lettuce, Tomato, Scallion, Bacon Lardons, Avocado, Blue Cheese Crumbles, Soft-Boiled Egg
Sides
  • Crispy Smashed Potatoes $10
    Sour Cream & Chives
  • Charred Asparagus $10
  • CRISPY ONION STRINGS $10
    Dijon Aioli
  • Sautéed Spinach $10
    Garlic & Olive Oil
  • PARMESAN TRUFFLE FRIES $12
  • Sea Salt Fries $10
*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk for foodborne illness.
Cocktails
Classics
  • SMOKY OLD FASHIONED
    elijah craig small batch bourbon, walnut & angostura bitters, sugar cube, orange half-moon, amarena cherry
  • PERFECT MANHATTAN
    rittenhouse rye, sweet & dry vermouth, amarena cherry
  • BLUECOAT NEGRONI
    bluecoat gin, campari, sweet vermouth, orange peel
  • PALOMA
    100% agave blanco tequila, grapefruit, lime, fever tree pink grapefruit
  • RITTENHOUSE WHISKEY SOUR
    rittenhouse rye, lemon juice, orange juice, simple syrup
  • MOSCOW MULE
    Grainger’s Organic Vodka, Lime Juice, Fever Tree Ginger Beer Cocktail Sparlkling
  • APEROL SPRITZ
    Aperol, Prosecco, Slice Of Orange
Martinis
  • CLASSIC MARTINI
    Six Dogs Distillery Karoo Gin, Dry Vermouth, Double Lychee Garnish
  • LYCHEE MARTINI
    E11even Vodka, Lychee Liquor, Dry Vermouth, Double Lychee Garnish
  • FRENCH MARTINI
    Tito’s Handmade Vodka, Chambord Raspberry Liquor, Pineapple Juice
  • BLACK CHERRY MARTINI
    Black Cherry Infused Vodka, Culch Vodka, Sweet Vermouth, Amarino Cherry
  • MR. BLACK ESPRESSO MARTINI
    Sobieski Vanilla Vodka, Espressso, Mr. Black Cold Brew Liqueur, Simple Syrup
Jumbo Bloody Mary
3oz of Grainger’s organic Vodka and our 1884 Bloody Mix with the Proper Accruements
$20
ADD SHRIMP +$3 each
Currents
  • QUEEN’S GAMBIT
    empress 1908 original indigo gin, st. germain elderflower liqueur, white cranberry, fresh lemon juice
  • POMEGRANATE COSMOPOLITAN
    grainger’s citrus vodka, pomegranate juice, cointreau, fresh lime juice
  • SPICY CUCUMBER MARGARITA
    Curamia Blanco Tequila, Triple Sec, Fresh Lime Juice, Simple Syrup, Jalapeño & Cucumber
  • WOOBLY BOOTS
    Grainger’s Organic Vodka, Aperol, Apple Cider, Lemon Juice, Cinnamon Syrup, Prosecco
  • PAPER PLANE
    Elijah Craig Small Batch, Averna Amaro, Aperol, Lemon Juice
  • BOURBON SIDECAR
    Woodford Reserve, Cointreau, Lemon Juice, Orange Twist
  • THE SINNER
    Irlandés Blanco, Lime & Pineapple Juice With Tajín Salt Rim
Wine
glass/bottle
SPARKLING
  • PROSECCO $14/$52
    tullia · veneto
  • CHAMPAGNE $135
    veuve clicquot · nv, reims
ROSE
  • ROSe $14/$50
    prophecy · california
  • ROSE $16/$58
    cht. berne romance · provence
  • ROSE $68
    silverado borreo sangiovese ‘21 · napa valley
WHITE
  • ALBARINO $15/$58
    burgans ‘23 · rias baixas
  • CHARDONNAY $17/$66
    oberon ‘22 · carneros
  • CHENIN BLANC $18/$68
    toad hollow vineyards · california
  • GODELLO $15/$55
    a telleira ribeiro ‘23 · spain
  • PINOT GRIGIO $14/$48
    circa ‘24 · veneto
  • SANCERRE $18/$69
    grand fossil ‘23 · loire Valley
  • SAUVIGNON BLANC $15/$55
    the little sheep ‘23 · new zealand
  • BOURDEAUX BLANC $72
    cht graville-lacoste ‘23 · graves
  • CHARDONNAY $80
    frank family ‘23 · napa valley
  • FIANO DI AVELLINO $65
    di meo ‘21 · campania
  • SAUVIGNON BLANC $65
    earthsong dillon’s point ‘22 · marlborough
  • SAUVIGNON BLANC $80
    frog’s leap ‘23 · napa valley
  • SANCERRE $82
    les glories ‘23 · loire valley
red
  • CABERNET SAUVIGNON $16/$50
    margarett’s vineyard ‘23 · california
  • CÔTES-DU-RHÔNE $15/$49
    m. chapoutier belleruche ‘23 · france
  • MALBEC $13/$51
    pie de palo ‘22 · mendoza
  • PINOT NOIR $16/$58
    la crema ‘23 · monterey, california
  • BORDEAUX $57
    cru monplaisir ‘21 · bordeaux
  • BURGUNDY $155
    louis latour ‘22 · beaune
  • CABERNET SAUVIGNON $55
    ghost pines · nv california
  • CABERNET SAUVIGNON $135
    heitz cellar ‘19 · napa valley
  • CABERNET SAUVIGNON $70
    seven hills ‘22 · walla walla valley
  • CHIANTI CLASSICO $65
    badia a coltibuono ‘21 · tuscany
  • PINOT NOIR $82
    argyle ‘23 · willamete valley
Tequila
  • CASAMIGOS AÑEJO
    Oaxaca, Mexico
  • CASAMIGOS BLANCO
    Oaxaca, Mexico
  • CASAMIGOS REPOSADO
    Oaxaca, Mexico
  • DEL MAGUEY VIDA ARTESANAL MEZCAL
    oaxaca, mexico
  • DON JULIO BLANCO
    jalisco, mexico
  • Don Julio Reposado
    jalisco, mexico
  • CURAMIA AÑEJO
    jalisco, mexico
  • CURAMIA BLANCO
    jalisco, mexico
  • CURAMIA REPOSADO
    jalisco, mexico
  • Patron Silver
    jalisco, mexico
Beer & Cider
DRAFT BEER
  • BROOKLYN LARGER $9
    new york
  • KILLSNER GERMAN PILLSNER $9
    staten island
  • GOOSE ISLAND IPA $9
    chicago
  • GUINNESS $10
    ireland
  • KONA BIG WAVE GOLDEN ALE $9
    hawaii
  • MONTAUK EASY RISER WITBIER $9
    new york
  • SIXPOINT BENGALI IPA $9
    new york
  • STELLA ARTOIS $9
    belgium
BOTTLES & CANS
  • 3 FLOYDS ZOMBIE DUST $10
    indiana
  • BUDWEISER $8
    missouri
  • BUD LIGHT $8
    missouri
  • COORS LIGHT $8
    colorado
  • MICHELOB ULTRA $8
    missouri
  • CORONA $8
    mexico
  • HEINEKEN $8
    netherlands
  • DOC’S CIDER $10
    new york
NEAR BEER
  • HEINEKEN 0.0 $8
    netherlands
  • ATHLETIC FREE WAVE HAZY IPA $9
    connecticut
Zero Proof
  • VINADA AIREN SPARKLING NON-ALCOHOLIC WHITE WINE
    netherlands
  • PUTTIN’ ON THE SPRITZ
    ghia apertif, passionfruit puree, vinada sparkling ‘wine’, bab louie orange bitters, simple syrup, orange wheel, fresh mint
  • NOT-SO OLDE FASHIONED
    lyre’s american malt, bab louie orange bitters, demerara simple syrup, orange wheel & amarena cherry