There’s something about eating classic burgers and fries in New York that feels iconic, especially when the setting has as much character as P.J. Clarke’s. At the original Third Avenue location, the food comes with the atmosphere of a historic restaurant that has been part of the city since 1884.
P.J. Clarke’s serves classic American cuisine in a space that takes you back to old-school New York. The meal may be familiar, but the experience has real personality, shaped by a rich history of those who enjoyed burgers (and named them) before.
Classic Burgers With a Real New York Story
P.J. Clarke’s has earned its place in New York dining culture, and the Cadillac Burger remains one of the restaurant’s most recognizable menu favorites. Its name dates back to the late 1950s, when Nat King Cole visited P.J. Clarke’s and tried the bacon cheeseburger. He dubbed it “the Cadillac of Burgers,” a phrase that meant something top-of-the-line at the time. In other words, Nat King Cole named it the best burger and fries in NYC!
We’ve maintained the same comfort food standard today. The Cadillac Burger is built around a freshly ground beef patty topped with double-smoked bacon and American cheese. A thick slice of raw onion sits beneath the burger on the bun. It adds flavor and catches the hot juices before they reach the bread, preventing the bun from going soggy. It is the kind of practical touch that gives this classic American cuisine staple extra character, with familiar burger toppings adding the final touch.
Classic Sides for Burgers That Complete the Meal
A burger can stand on its own, but the right side adds that extra oomph. Sea salt, hand-cut fries bring crispness and saltiness, while onion strings can add a little more crunch when you are in the mood for something richer. A lighter option like a side salad can also work well when you want contrast beside a hearty burger. These classic sides for burgers round off the perfect meal at P.J’s.
Finding the Right Classic Burger and Drink Pairing
A burger and a good drink belong together, especially at a restaurant where the bar is as much a part of the experience as the dining room. At P.J. Clarke’s, there are various cocktails to pair with your meal.
An Old Fashioned works beautifully with a rich bacon cheeseburger. Its mellow, spirit-forward flavor boosts the richness of the beef and cheese, while a Manhattan brings a sharper edge for diners who prefer something more classic.
The best classic burger and drink pairing is not about following a strict formula; it’s about choosing something that fits both the food and the mood. Speak to us about flavorful pairings that work with your menu choice – we will guide you to the best ones!
More Than a Casual Burger Stop
P.J. Clarke’s is a casual NYC restaurant, but it has the kind of atmosphere that makes guests want to stay a little longer. You can come in for a burger and fries, take a seat at the bar for cocktails, or begin with something from the P.J. Clarke’s Raw Bar before moving on to the main course.
More Than a Casual Burger Stop
P.J. Clarke’s is a casual NYC restaurant, but it has the kind of atmosphere that makes guests want to stay a little longer. You can come in for a burger and fries, take a seat at the bar for cocktails, or begin with something from the P.J. Clarke’s Raw Bar before moving on to the main course.
The Complete P.J. Clarke’s Experience
There is a reason classic burgers and fries remain one of New York’s most dependable pleasures. A good burger, hot fries, and a drink that fits the meal can make for one of those iconic meals that America has come to love.
Planning an occasion? Check out Private Affairs at P.J. Clarke’s for event dining, or make a reservation at your favorite table.
Frequently Asked Questions
What burger is P.J. Clarke’s known for?
The Cadillac Burger is the recommended burger for anyone trying P.J. Clarke’s for the first time. It remains one of the restaurant’s best-known menu favorites and gives you a real taste of the restaurant’s burger tradition.
What sides go well with a burger at P.J. Clarke’s?
For a first visit, hand-cut fries make the most classic choice. Onion rings (or strings) work well when you want extra sharpness, while a salad gives the meal a lighter balance.
What drinks pair well with a classic burger?
Ask the bar team for flavorful pairings from the cocktails menu based on your burger choice and whether you prefer something crisp or spirit-forward.
Can I make a reservation at P.J. Clarke’s?
Yes. Reservations are available online by location. Walk-ins are also welcome, although bar seating is first-come, first-served.
